Ятрань (Умань)

[wd613]

With all due respect, but this aren't incorrect informations.
That was internationally coordinated, and based on the transmitter power alone, ERP CANNOT be estimated. ITU data is better than none.
And the data on polarization of transmitters in Lviv (which are supposedly incorrect) were taken.. from here, from ukrtvr.org. So what, is this service also lying?

I know that colleague has some problem with me, because he blocked me without a word from one day to the next, but let's not exaggerate))

As for the transmitter location - it changed some time ago and the broadcast was moved to the city. Who knows, maybe it has now returned to the mountain tower.

I was just assuming that based on previous experiences with FMList, wrong polarizations, wrong locations, etc. It's a database made by many people, and people can make mistakes, it's normal, the data quality also depends on the region. I wanted to see if there are more sources to compare with. I'm not sure if the ITU databases are publicly available, an FMList administrator colleague told me it needs an account to be accessed.

[SzymonPL]

I personally manage the data for Ukraine on FM List, as is the case with Slovakia and Poland. Unfortunately, detailed data is not published on the Ukrainian side - only the transmitter location and the power TRP. The Polish and Slovak administrations provide very detailed data and it is easier to maintain full data consistency there. Here - to some extent, basing the ERP power on the ITU is the only sensible solution (TRP isn't ERP).

ITU data is published here - https://www.itu.int/en/ITU-R/terrestrial/brific/Pages/default.aspx - but it is true that reviewing each document separately took me many days.. And the effect of this work is visible on FM List. In turn, I check the data on transmitting objects and polarization here, on ukrtvr.org - hence the information about mixed polarization in some cases.
I will only add that I follow the decisions of the National Council (https://www.nrada.gov.ua/) and if something changes, it quickly appears in the database.

I also have an .xlsx file from the Polish UKE, which also made my work easier at one time.

[admin]

People, stay calm. Nobody is perfect, for nobody this is a job and therefore we do what we can trying to collect and insert the most truthful information.

[wd613]

I personally manage the data for Ukraine on FM List, as is the case with Slovakia and Poland. Unfortunately, detailed data is not published on the Ukrainian side - only the transmitter location and the power TRP. The Polish and Slovak administrations provide very detailed data and it is easier to maintain full data consistency there. Here - to some extent, basing the ERP power on the ITU is the only sensible solution (TRP isn't ERP).

ITU data is published here - https://www.itu.int/en/ITU-R/terrestrial/brific/Pages/default.aspx - but it is true that reviewing each document separately took me many days.. And the effect of this work is visible on FM List. In turn, I check the data on transmitting objects and polarization here, on ukrtvr.org - hence the information about mixed polarization in some cases.

I also have an .xlsx file from the Polish UKE, which also made my work easier at one time.

Thanks for your hard work, the wrong data on FMList was about Romanian transmitters, and that led me to the false impression that there are other irregularities on the site. I will try to think more before I write next time

[admin]

People, stay calm. Nobody is perfect, for nobody this is a job and therefore we do what we can trying to collect and insert the most truthful information.

And remember there is a war going on, some of the information is simply hidden and some is simply left out of date on purpose.

[SzymonPL]

That's right, from the perspective of a country where missiles aren't flying overhead, it's completely different. Maybe it will be better someday, but the war also has to end. It's impossible to obtain all possible data, but the more of us there are, the better the database can be maintained.
Slava Ukraini!

101.6 Zakarpattya FM - new PI Code: 6409

[Radio_2019]

Був PI Code: 6208